When a small bakery in Salt Lake City, Utah received a cease and desist from Pillsbury for trademark infringement, there was significant shock from the bakery, and its fans. After all, despite the fact that the bakery is named,
"My Dough Girl" , its menu which is characterized by 1950's style pin-up characters rather than any kind of doughy cartoon character or mascot. In fact, when we first heard about the situation, it took us a while to make the connection between My Dough Girl's name and Pillsbury at all since Pillsbury's Dough Boy character is almost always associated directly with the Pillsbury name.
Unfortunately for Pillsbury, whether they have a legitimate reason for legal action or not (trademark law is meant to eliminate consumer confusion between established brands and new products) the public has turned against them in another case of social media activism.
When the fans of the bakery found out about the cease and desist, they rallied around the bakery’s cause creating a Facebook page titled,
“My Dough Girl vs. Pillsbury Corporation” (below) which already has almost 2,000 fans willing to stand up for the small bakery and cut Pillsbury (an consequently General Mills, the conglomerate their owned by) down to size.
At the end of the day, the reason that this story has received attention is isn’t because the bakery is fighting back at all (the owner of the bakery isn’t responsible for the Facebook page) but because the bakery’s fans took to an outlet available to them, namely social media, and are willing to use the platform to fight back against what they see as the bullying of a small business by a large brand.
While no lawsuit has actually been filed against the bakery the threat in itself is dangerous enough to a small business (Pillsbury’s market capitalization is $23 billion), which probably accounts for the outpouring of support it’s receiving from its loyal fans. Ironically,
a story published by Salt Lake City Weekly states that as part of the cease and desist, Pillsbury’s lawyer instructed the bakery’s owner that she couldn’t speak to the press in an attempt to keep the situation under wraps. Unfortunately for General Mills (who obviously doesn’t really understand the way that social media works), all that the situation has done is proven that even loyal fans of Pillsbury's brand are disgusted by their actions (see screenshot below), and that fans of My Dough Girl, are willing to fight for a brand they respect.
As one fan claiming to be a lifetime Pillsbury purchaser says, "I grew up on Pillsbury stuff. I'm disgusted about this whole thing with My Dough Girl. Sad. I will not be buying any pillsbury products again."
So the real question becomes, despite the supposed trademark infringement claimed by Pillsbury and General Mills, is the issue really worth the brand damage they seem to be facing? While the issue is still relatively small, when it comes to social media the chance than an issue will go viral is always just waiting to happen, and the more publicity an issue gets, the more likely it is that something like that will happen.
As of yet, neither Pillsbury or General Mills have deigned to respond to any of the comments that have been made on their Facebook pages (screenshot below), a huge mistake in our opinion. Pillsbury opened themselves up to this criticism (although it is likely they had no idea what turn the situation would take) and without using social media as a platform to address the issue and their disgruntled fans, they aren’t helping their brand reputation.
As one commenter on the
General Mills Facebook Page says, "I wish General Mills wasn't so bent on running a mom-run business into the ground. They're
worried about icon branding confusion (My Dough Girl – 40s pin ups, Pillsbury Dough Boy… not a 40s pin up), well actions speak louder than words, and we’re
getting an up front view of just what their “Icon” stands for. Nothing but ...a bully. "
You can read other opinions on this situation at
TechDirt,
KSL.com and
The Future Buzz.
If you're interested, you can read more about our opinion on
managing your brand with social media or some tips on
being authentic and transparent in your social media use.